Highways, Development Pollute San Franciscans' Lungs, Mission Is Unhealthiest Hood

Mike Koozmin
Bad Breathe In
Every day may as well be a Spare the Air day.

A few key congested roadways help make lung problems -- including cancer and Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease -- along with heart disease the chief long-term health problems in San Francisco and the greater Bay Area, according to a new review of what makes American cities sick.

While MIT's report on Health and Urbanism finds San Franciscans healthier than most folks in Atlanta, Chicago or New York City, riding bikes and taking transit no further than 1.5 miles away from a big-time road means the C&C of SF mean the most densely populated county in the Bay Area may be its unhealthiest.

Obesity and diabetes clock in as the worst worries in most other cities, which means that they can at least run off their problems -- we can't move highways or densely packed blocks.

And the worst neighborhood for "health outcomes"? It may surprise you (and all its fixies, too).

The Mission District. And the reason is: density.

San Franciscans do report higher levels of fitness and lower rates of obesity than more car-centric Los Angeles and Sacramento. And while the last few weeks of cold, windless days have created a smog soup over the Bay SFist compared unfavorably to Shanghai, L.A. still has the worst air of all, the report found.

That said, wherever you are, there are cars -- and they're polluting. It may be easy to forget, but there are no less than four major highways slashing through the city (Highway 1, Interstates 80 and 280, and Highway 101). With everyone no further away than 10-15 minutes from a busy truck and car route, there's particulate matter to spare, which is directly related to chronic obstructed pulmonary disorder, or COPD.

There's one way to fix the highway air, and it's not a route San Francisco planners are taking. Most might expect neighborhoods like South of Market, next to the Bay Bridge, or Bayview (which sits in between a nuclear-related Superfund site and Highway 101) to be the city's unhealthiest.

In the Outer Mission, where highways are just as close by, the housing stock allows for courtyards and backyards -- backyards that abut each other, giving the air plenty of space to breathe. That's not the case in the Mission proper, where smaller and denser blocks of old wood-frame housing leave less permeable space.

Denser areas have the worst air. While the report suggest residents demand street trees near highways and planners accommodate them, there's a "direct link" between no open space and lung problems, according to the report. As if the anti-development set needed another reason to hate Mayor Ed Lee's beloved construction cranes.

Another woe for San Francisco: heavy drinking and sexually transmitted diseases. About 21 percent of San Francisco residents say drinking is a health concern, and STD infection rates are double rural counties.

So, we're a party town. And a highway town.

We can breathe easier than we have for most of December, anyway. After stagnant pollution gave sunsets on Tuesday a brilliant coppery glow, winds and Karl the Fog have at last returned and blown much of it away, with air quality two-thirds better today and Friday.

My Voice Nation Help
aliasetc topcommenter

In other words, Frisco is a town full of VD infected drunks!


"And the reason is: density."

That word, "reason," it does not mean what you think means.

Sumi Allen
Sumi Allen

Alcohol definitely weakens your immune system. And I've seen many more FIT people and RUNNERs. Not on the 10 freeway, but in Brentwood, SM, Hollywood, Beverly Hills, WEHO's gyms (ALL of them!), the wicked fast cross country runners in Thousand Oaks, the collegiate cross country meets in Agoura Hills...you'd be surprised if you'd actually just show up! :) Unless the only people you can see are white, then that's another big problem people from Frisco have.

Sumi Allen
Sumi Allen

The "skinny" San Franciscans I've seen are junkies. They're not exactly "fit". Def. not in contrast to Los Angeles. The people who ARE exercising do have a healthier immune system. It's true, esp. if they're eating right. Not a bunch of coconut oil, ALA, or fats which are INFLAMMATORY. BTW, been in LA for a while and haven't had lung issues yet. Maybe taking vitamins and getting nutrition instead of smoking crack, meth or doping up heroine might help.

johnny137 topcommenter

In other news: DRAMA.

Rock Belt
Rock Belt

Sidewalk smokers are a bigger factor than vehicular traffic to the health of pedestrians.

Now Trending

From the Vault


©2014 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.