America's Cup: Losing Millions Is the Exact Scenario We Were Warned About, Repeatedly

Let's all take a bath
The news over the weekend that the city could be left holding the bag for millions the America's Cup Organizing Committee has failed to provide is a revelation in the same sense that it's revelatory that promiscuous couples in horror films tend to be killed off.

The very real possibility of San Francisco being made to cough up scores of millions of America's Cup dollars is, in fact, the exact scenario warned of by prudent city officials not cheerleading for the event. Just as so many filmgoers futilely shout "don't go in there!" to ill-fated protagonists, so San Francisco was warned regarding the America's Cup.

We went in there. And now it may cost us. And, in fact, it may cost us a bit more than the (dismal) figures bandied about over the weekend.

See Also: The Cup Runneth Over

According to the most recent analysis by the Board of Supervisors Budget and Legislative Analyst, the estimated cup costs the city will incur stand at $40.2 million. The Port of San Francisco is pouring $21.9 million into the effort, $3.7 million of which do not come with longterm, non-cup benefits.

So, even if the private fundraisers hit their $32 million goal, the city could come up short. And it doesn't look like that goal will be hit; the money has purportedly dried up at $14 million. Keep in mind that much of that was a hand-me-down from the race organizers they described to SF Weekly last year as an "$8 million payment from [race organizers] characterized as an advance on future sales to be derived from a revenue-sharing split on sponsorships."

Avast! To the phones! Fundraise, men!
Apparently it's hard to fundraise on behalf of yachting billionaire Larry Ellison -- a fabulously wealthy man with a reputation for surliness and megalomania.

This was pointed out years ago, as was the incredible wiggle room afforded the private fund-raisers tasked with offsetting the city's costs. Within the lengthy contract, it says -- in writing -- they will "endeavor" to raise the $32 million. The nuance here, especially for anyone who's ever told his or her spouse that "I'll try" to do something, is all too apparent. The fundraisers could come up with a dollar and a quarter and still have met their end of the bargain.

"Not one cent" in private funds is guaranteed, Budget Analyst Harvey Rose told us in November 2010. "So there's no guarantee whatsoever we'll get that $32 million." Too bad: "If they don't raise the money, it's on the city," city Controller Ben Rosenfield told us in February 2012.

The budget analyst conveniently estimated that, if private fundraising stalled at around its current take, the city stands to lose some $11 million. This, however, is assuming $20.3 million in hotel taxes from visitors who will supposedly inundate our fair city. That may not happen. Of course, if fewer people show up, you'll stretch the cops, Muni, and other services less, requiring less city money. So that's good. But you won't have the billion-dollar impact on local business the mayor and others keep repeating. So that's bad.

In any event, this ship has set sail. Despite the dire fiscal risks we were warned of, clearly and repeatedly, we have charted this course. You'd think that those responsible for putting us in this bind would lose a little credibility. But they've got other things to think about.

They want us to host the Olympics. Of course they do.

My Voice Nation Help
mblaircheney topcommenter

As I wrote in response to another article, by Mr. Eskenazi, taking shot's at how bad the City is doing by hosting this historic America's Cup... 'The Fat Lady' hasn't sung yet. San Francisco in all it's glory will be on video screens all over the planet as the races take place... a live post card inviting all to pleasures to be had in the Bay Area. Rent that much time, at going advertising rates, to showcase San Francisco... like Countries and Cities due to promote tourism. America's Cup with us as 'product placement'. Beats the hell out of the Bay to Breakers or the latest nudist frightening small children... The World Series and NFL Announcers wax poetic as they describe the small snippets of San Francisco video in between the action on the field... Hell the field of America's Cup is San Francisco... 


I see that one of the Supes most adamant that this is a great boon to the city and chastising colleagues for raising questions is none other than Mark Farrell, now the Chair of the Board's Budget Committee. Good times ahead for all!


It seems that despite dire warnings from the budget analyst and city Controller, it seems the mayor and others have led us up the garden path. How about a breakdown of the construction contracts associated with the cup? Perhaps an enterprising journalist could analyze which of them went to companies with ties (campaign contributions or even more blatant relationships) to city officials involved in bringing the cup here...

And the Olympics? Maybe some civic-minded soul or group should start organizing a preemptive legal challenge now.

Enlightin Won
Enlightin Won

that private party in YB Gardens cost about a million

Angelina Cruz
Angelina Cruz

haha who didnt know this would happen! the city spent time evict businesses from various piers for an event that hasnt garnered the attention it claimed.

Shane OssaMain
Shane OssaMain

maybe Lawrence Joseph Ellison would be willing to pick up the difference? i feel like this is his deal, plus i heard he's not doing to bad financially...

Marios Belibassakis
Marios Belibassakis

Little peoples' taxes pay the advertisement of a multinational computer technology corporation...

Andrew K.
Andrew K.

What about the environmental impacts to the bay as well?

Now Trending

Around The Web

From the Vault


©2014 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.