America's Cup: What the Hell Just Happened?

Ted Knight.jpg
Wait -- this is getting interesting!
In around an hour's time, the Board of Supervisors would have likely approved a sprawling America's Cup development plan that would have committed the city to reimbursing Larry Ellison's Event Authority up to $136 million -- perhaps into the 22nd century.

Instead, the city and race organizers yesterday summoned the media to Oracle Racing's remote lair at Pier 80, and announced a drastically scaled-down development plan that may cost the city less than $10 million. It was as if the world's most epic game of Jenga had come to an abrupt and thunderous finish -- and it was decided no one needed a large wooden tower after all.

The rapid transformation of the America's Cup from a sprawling real-estate deal -- with attendant sprawling costs -- to the amorphous, yet still massively pared-back scenario now in play demands one simple question: What the hell?

Here's a shot at that.

Between the end of 2010 and the end of last week, the anticipated costs for the America's Cup have soared toward the heavens. A deal the Budget Analyst penciled out as roughly break-even in late 2010 counted on the America's Cup Event Authority investing $55 million in pre-race costs, and being reimbursed by the city via long-term free leases and the title to Seawall Lot 330.

Prior to the deal's swift implosion, that total had swelled to $111 million (and $25 million more than that if the Event Authority opted to do work on Piers 26 and 28). And while the Event Authority is paying legal tender to facilitate this work, it's being paid back via decades' worth of rent credits for the spruced-up waterfront properties. As we noted yesterday, it's highly uncertain what local and state authorities would have permitted Ellison's people to do on their new scraps of land. So while their dollar investment was guaranteed, the form of what they could build to recoup it was not.

But that's just the back end of the deal. How about up front?

Pirate battle.jpg
Terms have changed -- and fast!
On Sunday, the San Francisco Business Times published a short interview with Richard Worth, chairman and CEO of the Event Authority. He noted that lining up sponsorships was "bloody tough," and let on that the organization was well behind when it came to amassing sponsorship dollars.

As such, the Event Authority wasn't exactly flush with other people's money to immediately plow into the increasingly dizzying bill for rehabbing Piers 30-32. That would mean the Event Authority would have to put its own funds -- Ellison dollars -- into paying for the work, with the aforementioned uncertainty about recouping the costs.

This may have triggered the weekend's come-to-Jesus moment -- though, of course, Jesus wouldn't have required a massive, space-age catamaran to move about the bay.

(It warrants mentioning, meanwhile, that while the city's development-related costs have shrunk by perhaps 90 percent, it will still cost an estimated $52 million in logistical costs -- police, Muni, etc. -- to host this event. If private fundraising fails, it's on the city.)

Finally, while all sides remain committed to holding the event, it appears much else is in flux. While Event Authority COO Stephen Barclay told SF Weekly yesterday that his organization obtaining Seawall Lot 330 was "off the table," city officials say it's only off until it may be put back on.

America's Cup Stamp-thumb-300x208.jpg
Eyes on the prize...
Jennifer Matz, director of the Mayor's Office on Economic and Workforce Development, said Seawall Lot 330, valued at $25 million, isn't totally out of play -- but may only be handed over to the Event Authority "if their expenditures add up to that amount. And, right now, we're nowhere in that realm."

It remains for the city and Event Authority to sit down in the next week and determine what, exactly, the race organizers are going to do, and how much -- and how -- the city and port will pay them for it. Matz said this isn't akin to starting over at square one as every possible expenditure has already been "scoped out" -- and, essentially, was in the costly deal that just evaporated. Now comes deciding what to still do. "We're left with something that was still within that $110 million of expenditures," she says. "We're left with some subset. And the port, with our assistance, will figure out how to pay for those."

So, that's the deal as it stands now -- or doesn't. But, on more than one occasion, the apparent arrangement between the America's Cup and the city has been radically altered.

It remains to be seen if there will be a third time.

Follow us on Twitter at @SFWeekly and @TheSnitchSF.

My Voice Nation Help
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Sorry folks, but you still have no idea what this event is going to cost the City nor are you properly prepared.  Do you think the Event Authority just gave up or do they know something we don't know?  Good luck with that.

Heather Mcneil
Heather Mcneil

Yay!  Now our beloved crumbling parking lot can continue to be a blight on the waterline.  I'm not sure how, exactly, the Event Authority would have recuperated the restoration and development costs, but if a billionaire was behind it we *know* it must have been nefarious.

Now the responsibility for the piers is back in the capable hands of the city.  If only it had several extra tens of millions of dollars .. perhaps a sailboat tax?


And would it be so nice,  if we had the same LOUD Voice to nix those gargantuan Stadium's designed for the 1% and paid for by the 99%, the opportunity to pare-down.

Roland Salvato
Roland Salvato

Congratulations to the people of San Francisco for having their would-be advocates wake up at the last moment to the horrendous deal we would have received.  We are happy that Aaron Peskin's group formed and filed a law suit, we are relieved that the Mayor finally started to listed to his budget manager, and we are satisfied that a couple (not all) district supervisors were still skeptical of the alleged benefits of this development deal masquerading as a boat race.

Jack Griffin
Jack Griffin

Great Roland, let's celebrate with a big party on Piers 30-32!  What a garden spot.  I assume you DO have a suggestion for what to do with Piers 30-32...   let them fall into the Bay, right.   Oh, then what is your suggestion?

Now Trending

From the Vault


©2014 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.