Mitchell Katz, Bay Area Winemaker, Sues Wife Over "Dirty DUI"

Categories: Local News
rachelmnop via Flickr
Mitchell Katz's divorce is dirtier than a dirty martini
East Bay winemaker Mitchell Katz, is suing his wife and Chris Butler, the notorious Contra Costa County private eye who has been at the center of a massive police scandal, claiming the two were in cahoots to trap him into getting a "Dirty DUI."

Katz, 48, filed a lawsuit last week in San Francisco court alleging that Butler, a former Antioch police officer, worked with Katz's wife,  Alicia Spenger, to ply him with alcohol and tip the cops off if he tried to drive his car. Their aim was for Spenger to gain leverage in a custody battle over the couple's two sons, according to the lawsuit.

In November 2010, Spenger met with Butler, explaining how she was "very, very, very angry -- very angry," according to the claim. Butler assured her that there was a good possibility they could have Katz arrested for driving under the influence by engineering a ruse, which he liked to call a "Dirty DUI."

Spenger agreed to the plan and allegedly paid Butler $6,601.17 to have him pull off the DUI. On Jan. 14, Katz was at the Vine wine bar in Danville, where he was supposed to be meeting with a television producer named "John" who had said he wanted to create a reality TV show based on Katz's winemaking business. While they were there, "John" and others who were part of the ruse bought Katz several rounds of drinks.

Katz ended up consuming more alcohol than he would have, according to the claim.

When Katz left the Vine he was immediately pulled over by Deputy Tanabe with the Contra Costa County Sheriff's Department -- without probable cause. Katz was arrested on suspicion of driving under the influence and booked into jail. It was later learned that Tanabe had been tipped off by "John," who was working with Butler, according to the lawsuit.

It doesn't stop there. His wife then allegedly paid Butler an extra $1,500 to have his actors continue the ruse by bringing in a fake TV crew to film Katz's winery. A few months later, "John" whose real name is Carl Marino, a former officer himself hired by Butler, sent Katz an e-mail confessing to his role and apologizing for the incident.

According to the e-mail Marino sent:
I hope you are doing well. The first thing I wanted to do was apologize to you for my part in the setup. As you can see I never wanted to be involved in Butler's shady activities which is why I put an end to them and let the DOJ [Department of Justice] know what was done to you and others."
According to the suit, Tanabe's partner, Deputy William Howard, noticed that Tanabe kept getting calls from his "PI buddy" on the night that Katz was pulled over. When he asked him about it, Tanabe told him they were about to conduct a dirty DUI. Deputy Howard felt uncomfortable with the arrest, but because of his lack of experience he went along with it, according to the claim.

Katz is seeking punitive damages for civil rights violations, bad faith arrest, conspiracy, negligence, abuse of process, false imprisonment, and constitutional violations.

Follow us on Twitter at @SFWeekly and @TheSnitchSF
My Voice Nation Help

How do you know when Mitch is lying....when his lips are moving!


Mitch Katz is a great guy.  If you knew him, you wouldn't say that!

Pete B
Pete B

How pathetic to reply - these cops are going down and I've personally encountered - in my case we have three separate cases that could be construed as attempted murder


well that's a pack of lies.... Alicia had nothing to do with Mitch getting a DUI... don't forget... He WAS drunk and driving!


Its really a sad story if she did this to over a custody battle.Nobody get's hurt except the kids, but I'm sure she never thought about that.

Now Trending

From the Vault


©2014 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.