Ed Lee's Praise of PG&E Draws Fire

San Bruno Fire Smi23le 02.jpg
You take the good, you take the bad...
Mayor Ed Lee's kind words for PG&E -- a company whose name conjures up horrific images of fire -- are drawing some fire of their own.

Fellow mayoral candidates Dennis Herrera and John Avalos this morning issued press releases blasting Lee's "lavish praise" for PG&E. As quoted in this Examiner article, Lee presided over a heartwarming, press-friendly event featuring kiddies, baseball, and the company that blew up the adjacent town.

PG&E donated $250,000 to a program promoting baseball and literacy among San Francisco tots, which elicited this Lee quote: "Isn't that a wonderful contribution from a great local corporation? ... They're a great company that gets it."

That this donation came two days after the National Transportation Safety Board chastised PG&E for its carelessness and one day after a gas leak led to a Cupertino house going up like an old Christmas tree was coincidental, according to the company. 

In any event, Herrera let it be known that he has no interest in praising PG&E. He'd rather bury them, noting he's filed a "notice of intent" to sue government regulators for inadequately overseeing PG&E pipelines.

Herrera, in the midst of an endorsement meeting -- not with a newspaper that's spent nearly half a century targeting PG&E, by the way -- was not available for an interview. Nor was Avalos. Lee's camp, however, claimed the criticism of the mayor was mere grandstanding -- at the expense of fire victims and disadvantaged, illiterate kids, no less.

"Mayor Lee's comments praised PG&E's support of a literacy program -- period," said Lee spokesman Tony Winnicker. "Holding PG&E accountable for the loss and suffering they caused doesn't mean not recognizing them when they do something good."

Winnicker then passed SF Weekly's contact info to Jim Messemer, the founder and CEO of RBI, the nonprofit that benefited from PG&E's largess. Messemer noted he was "very thankful" the mayor and others have backed his charitable efforts, to which PG&E has helped to provide "desperately needed" resources. "Our primary initiative is around literacy. ... The fact this has become political, it really breaks my heart."

Baring an unforeseen gas leak and its fiery aftermath, we'll update this article when Herrera and Avalos call back.

Update, 2:05 p.m.: Herrera rejected Winnicker's suggestion that he "owed an apology" to the victims of the San Bruno fire for supposedly exploiting them as part of a political ploy. Rather, said the city attorney, the mayor should choose his words more carefully.

"You can sit there and thank a company or individual without calling them 'a great company' that 'gets it,'" Herrera says. "Clearly, if you look at their relationship with the community and ability to keep the community safe, they're not getting it done in that area. Sure, everyone appreciates the contribution to help literacy. But I don't think that's a very good choice of words." 

Update, 4:15 p.m. Supervisor John Avalos questions why Lee would "help PG&E do its PR work and make themselves look like a peachy outfit."

A $250,000 donation to needy kids "doesn't make a multibillion-dollar corporation a 'great corporation.' You don't have to say PG&E is a 'great corporation.'"

Follow us on Twitter at @SFWeekly and @TheSnitchSF 

My Voice Nation Help
Sort: Newest | Oldest

PG&E is a big company.  Just because some of the people in it were negligent or greedy doesn't make the whole company bad--that's like someone saying that all Americans are greedy because they saw a news report about Bernie Madoff.  PG&E also puts a lot of money into energy efficiency research, so they won't *have* to build big gas pipelines in future.


PG&E doesn't "put a lot of money into energy efficiency research" out of the kindness of their hearts.  The IOUs were required to make investments in EE under the 1996 law that deregulated the energy industry.  Over time, it's become clear that PG&E hasn't met the EE targets that the CPUC has required and has spent much of the money allocated for EE measures on short-term measures that are used to support high shareholder incentives.  Please don't think its EE program is an indication of how great they are.


Lee is friends with Willie Brown and Newsom, so how is is love of PG&E a surprise?

Now Trending

From the Vault


©2014 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.