Athena Wortham, Woman Who Killed Intruder Who Choked Her, Is Accused of Murder

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for crimescenetape1.jpg
Is self defense murder?
Athena Wortham was asleep in her home on Sunday morning when she woke up to find an intruder allegedly trying to strangle her. She did what anyone who was fighting for their life might do -- she killed him.

But now an apparent act of self defense has landed her in jail. San Francisco police said they arrested 42-year-old Wortham on suspicion of murder.

"I'm not sure exactly why, but as of now she is charged with murder," says Officer Carlos Manfredi. "The inspectors have to look into whether she was a victim or a suspect -- or both." Wortham was asleep inside her Bayview home on the 700 block of Kirkwood Avenue at about 4:47 a.m. when she heard noises. She woke up and allegedly found 40-year-old Anthony Payne strangling her. Manfredi said she grabbed a knife and stabbed him to death.

While she told police she was acting in self defense, there was enough reason for inspectors to believe she murdered him, he said.

"As long as you are in danger you have the right to protect yourself," Manfredi told us. "All I can say is it is an active investigation."

Follow us on Twitter at @TheSnitchSF and @SFWeekly

My Voice Nation Help

That's what happens when you wait to call police for an hour after you stab someone.

Elizabeth Frantes
Elizabeth Frantes

Typical SF "justice" ATTACK THE VICTIM WHO FIGHTS BACK.  So either you let yourself get raped/murdered, and then the DA drops the charges to simple assault, or you fight back and YOU get charged!  THAT'S WHY I'M SUPPORTING FAZIO.   SF needs a DA, not more PDs. 

Jesse Powell
Jesse Powell

Thank goodness someone who was at the scene has come forward to offer the unvarnished truth. Case closed! Oh. Wait. You weren't there? You don't actually know what happened? You just wanted to make a political point? ... Someone might say that is "typical" of something. 


All right, fair enough. Homicide it is!

Now Trending

From the Vault


©2014 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.