Will Stow Lake Affair Sink City Attorney?

Categories: Law & Order
Sinking ship.JPG
Is the S.S. Dennis Herrera taking on water?
Will the city attorney's office be kicked overboard as the latest casualty in the ongoing Stow Lake controversy? The answer may come as soon as next week.

The lake's concessions have been run by the McClellan family for generations. Bruce McClellan sued the city in March, however, after he lost his bid to continue running the family business to the Ortega family, which runs concessions in a number of parks nationwide. Backed by a trove of e-mails, McClellan claims city officials and the Ortegas sealed the deal well before the bidding process, then orchestrated a propaganda campaign to sell the public on the switcheroo. At the center of this alleged conspiracy was lobbyist Alex Tourk -- who was, until this week, City Attorney Dennis Herrera's consultant in his mayoral campaign.

At a Tuesday hearing regarding a potential injunction being placed on the transfer of the concession away from McClellan, his lawyers say the subject of whether Herrera's office is compromised in this case will all but certainly be broached. "It's disturbing to have so many close connections," says attorney Paul Rosenlund. "I think the city would be better advised if someone else handled" this case.

The City Attorney's office, naturally, sees things differently. This case doesn't present a conflict of interest, states Deputy City Attorney Francesca Gessner, because no one in the office is making a dime one way or the other depending on the outcome.

"Our role is to represent the Recreation and Park Department and the Board of Supervisors who awarded the lease," she says. "The legal issue is whether the city [abided by] all applicable bidding laws. Any allegations pertaining to Alex Tourk's lobbying are irrelevant to the legal issues."

Yorktown under attack.jpg
Stow Lake is far from placid these days...
The allegations regarding Tourk, she continued, are "a political sideshow." This term was used by several officials at the City Attorney's Office; it seems to be the city's preferred nomenclature for l'affaire d'Tourk. 

At the very least, doesn't it look bad that the city attorney's office is now defending the city in a matter where alleged wrongdoing was committed by a man on the city attorney's payroll? Do you need an expert to tell you the answer? Here's one.

"That sure doesn't look good!" says Carol Langford, an adjunct law professor at USF who specializes in legal ethics. Herrera's "going to say 'this is a big office and my deputies are on this -- and they don't give a shit about my campaign. I wasn't personally on the case.' I can see how he could say that. However, to me, it looks bad -- although there's no proof [the connection between Tourk and Herrera] somehow affected the case."

Fellow legal ethicists didn't see it the same way, however. Richard Zitrin said Herrera and his office are in the clear -- and would be even if Tourk hadn't quit Herrera's campaign earlier this week. "The job of the city attorney is to represent the city and the city has been sued. The fact Tourk is a figure who could be a witness doesn't mean the city can't be represented by its city attorney," he says. "It's not feasible to farm out cases because of a conflict of interest every time there's somebody known to the city attorney mentioned in a case."

Follow us on Twitter at @TheSnitchSF and @SFWeekly

My Voice Nation Help
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Think there should be some appreciation for a local SF family-business that has kept this place in operation and FUN for all sorts of families for years and years.  Why does everything in SF now need high-end gourmet food and wine.  Not what this place has been about.  Also, everyone should take a closer look at the email record to see that the result was based on a flawed and likely corrupt process that will add nothing for people who simply want to enjoy the lake and its history.


Hope so.   I'll do what I can to help the sinking ship go down.


 Wow, are the racists below in SF or Texas?

Herrera and Ortega, for better or for worse, come from Hispanic roots (judging by the Spanish surnames).

Immigrants contribute a tremendous amount to American society. Drugs are brought into this country with the cooperation of the highest levels of American and foreign novelists......


Race card is getting old, bring up facts.  Everyone knows, the race issue always comes up when you have no defense ! Try again. 


 Most cities in California are doomed due to latino immigration that the state refuses to adress.  Your relectance to obey federal law will soon be your demise.  This is just one case in the millions you are about to experience.  The latino will begin to elect each other into office, once they the majority; regardless of competence.  Then they'll take away your entire cities wtithout a battle !  Afterwards, you'll begin to realize that you have become a third world country and you will suffer all of the miserable crap that most latin countries have to live through.  The stealing, lying, and general disrespect for the law will cause most of the decent Americans to bail out before you turn into another mexico !  Just look at history and try to name one latino country worth a damn. I know because, I saw miami go from a paradise to a shit hole, so we left. Sorry, but these are the facts, leave your emtions at home.

Now Trending

Around The Web

From the Vault


©2014 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.