Giants Fans Beaten by Dodgers Fans, One in Critical Condition

• Being passive does not correct the path, either. I lived in LA for 5 years and witnessed first-hand that this is, unfortunately, NOT a generalization. Sometimes, you have to plain fight back. Simple as that.

• Idiot

• This is a very poorly written opinion piece. Dodger fans propensity for fighting eachother... Lol... How quickly you seem to forget the Giants fan who murdered an 18 year old fellow Giants fan at AT&T Park in 2008. Do us all a favor and do some research and try to write an objective piece instead of making wildly broad generalizations. No need to paint with such a broad brush. You also failed to mention that there were 4 Giants fans and 2 Dodger fans in this incident. The poor guys' friends left him to get stomped, unbelievable. Some pals.

• Thanks you for posting "Antibluebitch"; you've demonstrated my point perfectly. I hope I never run into you at AT&T Park.

• Death to all you failure So Cal Dodgers fans! Are you so miserable with your lives that you need to almost kill an innocent man???!!! Come to a Giants game cocksuckers, it's fucking ON!

• Agreed Becky, I heard about the story and somehow ended up at this site after googling.'Giants fan critical condition '. Physical violence is unacceptable but so is making generalizations about an entire fan base. I'm assuming this is more of a blog type site and not a news source, but still would be nice if they made an attempt at journalistic integrity. Time to find another link to an actual news item on the story.

• I can't help but think that this article make the elementary mistake of making huge generalizations that will only fuel more dumb idiots (on each side) to do more dumb things. When Ms. Smiley mentions, "You'd think they would have been satisfied with victory -- but apparently, Los Angeles fans wanted more," she alludes to the fact that all Dodger fans wanted to beat the crud out of other fans. Not so, and I wish sweeping generalizations would be left for the dumb idiots out there to make; it's a shame she had to stoop to this level.

• Those slobs, every one of them

TotalComments: 8