Witnesses: 5 Fulton Bus Hits Cyclist; Driver Refuses Passengers' Pleas to Stop

Bus bike crash 015.jpg
Joe Eskenazi
A cyclist lay bloody and dazed on Market near Fifth Street this morning, following a run-in with the 5 Fulton bus. More disturbingly, however, eyewitnesses told SF Weekly the bus driver refused to stop, even when passengers told him he'd hit a bike rider.

"People were like, 'You hit a bike, you need to stop,'" said Mary Chancey, a passenger on the 5 Fulton bus. "He said, 'She fell by herself.'"

Chancey said around 10 bus riders implored the driver to stop following the 8:30 collision -- but he instead left the scene. When SF Weekly arrived just before 8:40, the young female cyclist was lying in the middle of the road, and police and fire soon arrived.

Multiple eyewitnesses on the street confirmed to SF Weekly that the cyclist -- whose identity we were unable to ascertain -- was hit by the bus, which continued onward. The victim, who was talking to police and appeared to be moving, was loaded onto a gurney and taken away in an ambulance.

Muni spokesman Judson True said police and a Muni investigator are on the scene. "Clearly this is a serious allegation, and we are investigating it now," he noted. True said the initial report he's received is that the cyclist fell near the bus, which subsequently made contact with her and her bike -- which the mangled cycle SF Weekly observed on the scene attests to.

Bus bike crash 014.jpg
Joe Eskenazi
Police moved the cycle onto the sidewalk following the accident

UPDATE, 10:15 a.m.: True says that the reports he's hearing are that the rear wheels of the inbound 5 Fulton ran over the woman's cycle -- but that the bus did not make contact with the cyclist.

The operator of the bus has been interviewed by Muni and police. True confirms that Muni policy requires any driver who "has been told he or she may have been involved in a collision" to stop -- meaning this driver violated that policy according to multiple eyewitnesses.

Bus bike crash 012.jpg
Joe Eskenazi

Bus bike crash 016.jpg
Joe Eskenazi

Comments (12)

Hanna Quevedo says:

This happened to me in the exactly place. A taxi (jeep) opened the door in the bike line without to check if some bike was coming. The driver wanted to leave and a witness made him stop and get off from the car. Market is crazy and cars are more.

Posted On: Wednesday, Mar. 3 2010 @ 10:03AM
scurvy says:

Unions! Gotta love 'em! Exhibit one in any hothead who defends the union system.

Also, why was this person not immediately arrested? If anyone else did this, they would be arrested for a hit and run. Muni drivers get a pass both from Muni and SFPD?

Why do I feel like Slim Pickens riding the nuke down at the end of Dr. Strangelove?

Posted On: Wednesday, Mar. 3 2010 @ 10:55AM
VeloBusDriver says:

If one passenger tells me I hit something I STOP, set the emergency brake and investigate. Best case, they're mistaken and I get back on the bus and *then* drive off. Worst case, I actually hit somebody but in that case I'm there to take responsibility and see to it that any necessary medical assistance is called.

The Union has a responsibility to defend this driver, just like a defense attorney has a responsibility to defend their client. That said, it sure sounds like the witnesses in this case show that the driver violated policy. If that's shown to be true the driver deserves to disciplined.

Situations like this give all bus drivers a bad name.

Posted On: Wednesday, Mar. 3 2010 @ 11:30AM
Safetreetsnot says:

I feel for the rider and hope she was not permanently injured. Muni is the biggest hazards on to road for all. Drivers speed down streets...through pedestrian crosswalks...ripping around corners...barely making lights...and rarely pulling into bus zones. And we pay the drivers on average $70K bucks a year for all of this. I hope the driver is suspended WITH OUT PAY for the next several months. But I know that's not what will happen. No doubt he will be promoted with a pay increase and asked to train other drivers evasive driving techniques with the full support of the UNION.

Posted On: Wednesday, Mar. 3 2010 @ 12:17PM
exbusdriver says:

@VeloBusDriver

If the witnesses can confirm that these allegations are true, the driver needs more than 'discipline', he needs jail time.

Posted On: Wednesday, Mar. 3 2010 @ 2:45PM
Caitlyn says:

This is why I am afraid to attempt even riding my bike I have sitting in my apartment. I walk everywhere. I've witnessed first hand how horrible these drivers are. I use to have to take the 71 and it was terrible. It rarely showed up, it took forever to get home and some of the drivers were just horrible. But speaking of all bus lines. This one guy was being a real dick to my friend because he ripped his pass pulling it out of his pocket. I was like "he is with me, he isn't lying." That guy clearly sexist as hell. Was like "shut up, was I talking to you?" "What you need your lady to talk for you, you don't have enough balls." I was like wtf?? It was on bus 22. It's just sad, your suppose to be a public figure for the community and all your care about is your paycheck because the union is covering your ass!! This guy deserves to be throw in JAIL for hurting that girl!! And he should pay for a new bike!!

Posted On: Wednesday, Mar. 3 2010 @ 5:09PM
Cyclist&Driver says:

As far as MUNI being the biggest hazard on the road, I would disagree. Buses are easy to see and they move slow as hell. They run red lights all day long, but so does every other car piloted by a sociopath in this city. By far the biggest hazard on the roads today are the taxi cabs. The combination of so many drivers that learned to drive in countries that do not enforce traffic laws and the fact that the faster they drive, the more money they make, creates very unsafe streets. The odd thing is that unlike the MUNI situation that is a product of a sheltering union, the cab situation we could actually impact as individuals. Tell the next cab driver you ride with that if he breaks any laws, you won't tip him. They have it in their head that we all want to get to our destinations ASAP. If you make it clear that a SAFE ride is what you are looking for, they will do what it takes to get that tip. Try telling a MUNI driver that you would like them to drive safely or else....well people smoke crack and get in fist fights on the bus already so good luck with that.

Posted On: Wednesday, Mar. 3 2010 @ 7:35PM
Sunny Jim says:

I love the sight of a crumpled bike!

Posted On: Wednesday, Mar. 3 2010 @ 8:12PM
Michael Treece says:

I love the sight of a crumpled bike!

It's always amusing when the sociopaths start showing up.

Posted On: Thursday, Mar. 4 2010 @ 8:33AM
laughing out loud says:

How is this about unions? this is about one bus driver's irresponsibility. Obviously some cranks out there are just looking for a place to rant about their extremist agenda.

What have unions done for you? Not much, EXCEPT THE EIGHT HOUR DAY and THE WEEKEND.

Posted On: Thursday, Mar. 4 2010 @ 9:49PM
rfkolbe says:

I went down at that intersection some years ago.

I was new to the streets of San Francisco and I hit the gratings over the underground. There were so many nice people who helped after they saw me go down.

Sad to hear the driver didn't listen to passengers. He probably should be fired.

Posted On: Friday, Mar. 5 2010 @ 12:20AM
Charlie says:

Should be disciplined? Should be fired? He should be jailed. Hit and run should be taken seriously, according to CA law.

Posted On: Sunday, Mar. 7 2010 @ 7:09PM

Write Comment


Comments may not show up immediately after submission. Please wait a minute after posting a comment for it to appear.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking "Post," you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.

Sign up for free stuff, news info & more!

Tools

Links

Linkage

Newspapers: Daily

Newspapers: Other

Other Local Publications

Web Sites: Politics

Radio

Television