 |
| Phyllis Keating |
| Pete Townshend |
Last night, Who guitarist Pete Townshend made a rousing speech at a British radio festival, blasting Apple's iTunes store for its treatment of musicians "whose work it bleeds like a digital vampire." His speech even included a list of things Townshend believes Apple should do to encourage and support musical creativity.
While we're all for supporting musicians, Townshend's diatribe was sorely misguided and misinformed. In the interest of an honest conversation about the ailing music industry and what could be done about it, here are five of the things Townshend either didn't realize or got spectacularly wrong. You can read the full text of his lecture here.
1. Apple is a business -- a large, shrewd, brutally self-interested American corporation.
And it is solely concerned with its own growth and success. Certainly its products have had ancillary benefits to others, and to society at large -- including, ahem, musicians. But doing good for musicians is not what Apple is about. Unlike, say, the BBC, Apple is a for-profit entity that owes no inherent debt or responsibility to the American people (at least not legally, in the strict capitalist sense). So making a list of things the company should provide to musicians (out of the goodness of its $400-a-share heart?) seems not only naive, but idiotic.
More >>