San Francisco's 10 Best Sandwiches

Categories: Top Ten

Arguello_Market_Turkey_Sandwich.JPG
Jonathan Kauffman
Arguello Market's roast turkey sandwich.
​Given the care that San Francisco cooks lavish on the humblest of vegetables, it's no surprise that sandwich-making in this town qualifies as an artisanal pursuit. Even journeyman makers hunt down the perfect bread for their masterpieces and whisk together small-batch mayonnaise. In fact, we're surprised that no one has come up with a sandwich-making certification program. Or a guild. Or at least a manifesto. Then again, that's what we love about sandwiches. You can make a sandwich fancy, you can charge $14 for it, but in the end, it's still a food meant to be eaten with your hands. Here are our 10 favorite right now:

10. Turkey sandwich from Arguello Super Market (pictured above)
782 Arguello (at Golden Gate), 751-5121


This small grocery in the Richmond backs its roast turkey sandwich up with a big marketing push: 'World's best turkey sandwich." World's best? We can't judge that claim, but it's certainly San Francisco's best, layered with fat slices of meat sliced off a freshly roasted bird. The grocery store can roast up to a dozen birds a day, just to keep up with demand. With good meat in the middle, there's no need to zhoozh it up, though if you're feeling Novemberish, you can add cranberry sauce for an extra 75 cents.

MandL_pastrami_sandwich.jpg
Jonathan Kauffman
M&L's turkey and pastrami sandwich.
9. Turkey-pastrami sandwich at M & L Market
691 14th St. (at Market), 431-7044
Over the course of its 32 years, this mom-and-pop market, now more of a mom-and-daughter market, has developed rules so stringent they rival the U.S. Customs Service's. As numerous signs instruct, you must order the sandwich in a certain order -- bread first! -- and it helps to speak slowly and clearly, showing Judy and May deference rather than fear. The sandwich you get in return isn't just cheap, it's unique to the market, stuffed with sliced turkey and M&L's signature meat, a mild, fat-streaked pastrami that heats and crinkles up in two rice cookers.

Boos_Voni_Milanesa2.JPG
Jonathan Kauffman
Boos Voni's chicken milanesa torta.
8. Chicken milanesa torta from Tortas Boos Voni.

5170 Mission (at Geneva), 585-5880
American tortas are like American, well, everything: bigger, louder, cheesier than the Mexican original. The breaded chicken cutlet -- freshly fried -- at the center of Boos Voni's milanesa torta is padded out with an inch-thick layer of shredded lettuce, tomato, onion, and avocado, glued to the telera bread they're pressed between with fat doses of cotija cheese and crema. That girth, though, guarantees that the torta balances out the tang of the sour cream with the fresh crunch of the vegetables. Just make sure to split it with a friend.



Jablows_pastrami.JPG
Jonathan Kauffman
Pastrami sandwich from Jablow's Meats
7. Pastrami sandwich from Jablow's Meats

Various locations; check the Facebook page

For the past year, Dan Jablow, a former Fatted Calf butcher, has been selling his smoked meats at popup restaurants around town. And if his pastrami sandwich is hard to come by, it's worth the hunt. Jablow brines and smokes Piedmontese beef over apple and cherry wood, and it comes out is smokier and less salty than the stuff in your average deli sandwich. When the cooks slather the pastrami in whole-grain mustard, cover it in a vinegary slaw, and mount it between slices of thick-crusted rye, you get an excellent package, not a mediocre vehicle for good meat.

Location Info

Venue

Map

Arguello Super Market

782 Arguello, San Francisco, CA

Category: Restaurant

0 user reviews
Write A Review
Save to foursquare
Powered by Voice Places

Tortas Boos Voni

5170 Mission, San Francisco, CA

Category: Restaurant

Outerlands

4001 Judah, San Francisco, CA

Category: Restaurant

Pal's Takeaway

2751 24th St., San Francisco, CA

Category: Restaurant

Little Vietnam Cafe

309 Sixth Ave., San Francisco, CA

Category: Restaurant

Roli Roti Gourmet Rotisserie

San Francisco, San Francisco, CA

Category: Restaurant

Queen's Louisiana Po-Boy Cafe

3030 San Bruno Ave., San Francisco, CA

Category: Restaurant

Ironside

680 Second St., San Francisco, CA

Category: Restaurant

M and L Market

691 14th St., San Francisco, CA

Category: General

My Voice Nation Help
95 comments
Jonas Heineman
Jonas Heineman

There are sandwiches, and there are sandwiches. Arguello Super is the ONLY one on this list that qualifies as a legit sandwich from a sandwich place. Any list of sandwiches that doesn't include something from Ted's Market on Howard is bunk.

Monica Tzeng
Monica Tzeng

Good Luck Sandwich in Chinatown - a hole in the wall, but definitely gives more than what you pay!

Rebecca Palermo
Rebecca Palermo

It's been awhile since my SF days, but the Humboldt Fog Goat Cheese sandwich at Tartine and the tuna melt at the Dolores Park Cafe were two of my favorite things...

Michael Davidson
Michael Davidson

and Il Canne Rosso makes a roast beef that I would kill for.

David Oliver
David Oliver

Yes! Pal's Takeaway! Jeff's bahn mi is outta control! Best sandwich shop in the city!!

Annie Southworth
Annie Southworth

French Dip at Clare's Deli, Home for the holidays (Turkey and Sriacha Cranberry) at Ike's, Roast Beef Bi-Rite Market

Robert Tye
Robert Tye

i am in shock and awe that you failed to mention any sammich from Lou's Cafe

Katie Casey
Katie Casey

Elaine Ordiz hoping to live vicariously through you and this list!

Arielle Kelly
Arielle Kelly

i know this list is inaccurate because both molinari's and Soul Groove are not on it!

citysando
citysando

Nothing from morty's? They deserve to have something on this list along with Lou's in the richmond and Java beach in the outer sunset. I haven't seen anyone mention twilight cafe. Might not be the best sandwich u ever had but it's tasty, so is the one at grove st market. I tend to like the cheaper sando spots  

IMO
IMO

imo: negative: glad ike's was left off the list: simple is better and long lines are gay.

              wise sons is overpriced: wtf but i guess that includes gentrification.

positive:              rhea's deli isn't mentioned: their valencia st. is epic!               yay for mays & pals!

ps:  what is up with dutch cruch bread anyway?

basil
basil

I LIKE IKES!Granted the grilled cheese looked tasty, but I doubt there is a line of people wrapped around a City block to get one

SFoodie
SFoodie

Dude, go to the 7x7SF 2012 list for the real deal about what's good in SF.

Sandwich
Sandwich

This blog is a joke...if Ike's isn't on any sandwich top list in SF, they these writers don't know jack.

FriscoEddie
FriscoEddie

plilly cheese stake is better than all @ divisidero/ sutter

Monedog
Monedog

Ahhh, where's Deli Board, Rhea's Deli or Ike's??  My holy sandwich trinity!!!

Steven
Steven

Why no offering from Ted's market?  The best sandwiches in the city!

Eclipse
Eclipse

Sorry, but if Mr. Pickle isn't on this list I can't take it seriously.

Also where's the Saigon Sandwich? Best banh mi in town by a mile.

SO over the hipster reinventions of sandwiches..

Waybackgiant
Waybackgiant

A couple of pointers on the Cuban sandwich at Ironside. First of all, it's the wrong bread. Secondly I don't see any swiss cheese, the pickles shouldn't be chopped and where's the mustard? Other than that, it looks delicious.

Jbernsteiniii
Jbernsteiniii

The Original El Faro    20th & Folsom ..Carnitas Tota

George's Zoo  RJ's invention  2560 Sloat blvd

The Original Philadelphia Cheesesteak shoppe  Divisadero & Sutter..Spinach & Mushroom with sweet & hot, grilled onions ( 10 inch please)

Tommy's Joynt- Turkey Sandwich

The Yellow Submarine _ pepper steak & cheese (ask for the secret hot sauce)

Original Joe's Hamburger ( A hamburger IS a sandwich)

Lucca's deli ( Chestnut st)  A Mortadella, Prosciutto, Salami &  Provolone  will make you whack your grandma.

Miller's east Coast west- Corned Beef on Rye, Yellow mustard and a pickle- leave me alone, I'm eating.

The House of Bagels bakery and shop at 5030 Geary Boulevard- House of Bagels’ Special

Hot Corned Beef, Chopped Liver, Swiss Cheese, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing on Rye ( What's not to like?)

The last place is a secret. I'm not telling but, the sandwich is meatloaf done the right way. Besides, Mom doesn't like it when i bring people home.

jab
jab

sorry by leaving off Wise Sons Pastrami and incudling Jablow's pastrami instead you have NO credibility for taste!

Reggio
Reggio

How could you forget Molinari's.  There basil turkey special is the best!

Evan Goldin
Evan Goldin

DId you really have to spread this list out over 4 pages? Really makes me hate this website.

Also, Bite Deli should be on here. Or at least Deli Board. This list is kind of a joke -- it's clearly just trying to cater to all the various neighborhoods by places from all over the city.

Ziggy
Ziggy

What? No hot capiocola sandwich from Giordano Bros (can't beat fries and slaw on your sandwhich)!!!

Mankhost
Mankhost

Of course, these lists are subjective, but I do feel compelled to say that Wise Sons corn beef and pastrami sandwiches are miles ahead of any other in SF. Take my word for it as a Jew from NY.

Also, that oyster po' boy from queens is pretty damn good, but I would still give the nod to Brendas oyster po' boy

Other faves...The Dio at Alamo Sq. is fantasticThe veggie duck at Luv and HaightAnything at Cheese Plus on Polk and Pacific, Willie Brown Bird for exampleProsciutto and fresh mozz at LuccaBi-Rite, anything as well I must say

NB_12
NB_12

I second the Willie Brown Bird from Cheese Plus....so good! Boy's Deli on Polk is pretty solid too.

Clearly Ike's was only left off because its been on the Food Network and putting it on this list would not be very "hip".

anonomom
anonomom

No Saigon Sandwiches, Ike's, or Roxie's?  Pfft!

Kram1221
Kram1221

um, Saigon sandwich on Larkin -- hello!

Gaverc
Gaverc

Calabria Brother's is an amazing Italian Deli in Portero Hill and in the Excelsior--amazing Italian sandwiches--Jersey's in the Richmond is an amazing sandwich place too--Aguello is a given.

2 Vietnamese sandwich places is pushing it, but I haven't had both--but while those types of sandwiches are delicious, I've not noticed a huge amount of range in flavors.

Chris
Chris

No Roxies?  You, sir, do not know sandwiches.  Let me guess, you are a hipster from out of town.

Bshanmc
Bshanmc

How could you forget Jonas on Hyde?! Yum.

Unagi1
Unagi1

Freddy's in North Beach should be listed

Mollyzucker
Mollyzucker

Leaving off Giordano Brother's All in One sandwich discredits this entire list

Pinky
Pinky

Thank you for including Boos Voni. Proof he knows what a good sandwich is. Im not that impressed with Ike's or Roxie's, although I ate that growing up during middle school through college. I get EXTREMELY FREAKING thirsty after eating a sandwich from Ike's or Roxie's. I suspect they add a little msg to their sauces. Maybe that is the "secret"

NativeSF
NativeSF

MSG? I can't speak on Ike's, but Roxie's doesn't use MSG. #FACT

Pinky
Pinky

Also thanks for including QUEEN'S PO BOY. YES. simple, fresh, and SOO GOOD.

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

©2013 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places San Francisco / Bay Area

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city